As of September 2026, rental prices in Otay Ranch (91913), in the San Diego metro area, range from $2,709 to $5,509 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year decrease occurred in 3BR apartment rents in Otay Ranch, CA, falling -10.78%.
For 3-bedroom units, single-family homes have a median rent of $4,110, higher than apartments at $3,614.
What is the current range of rental prices in Otay Ranch, California?
As of September 2026, asking rents in Otay Ranch range from $2,709 per month for a 1-bedroom apartment to $5,509 per month for a 4-bedroom apartment.
Which rental type experienced the biggest annual decline in Otay Ranch, and was it isolated or broad?
The largest year-over-year rent drop in Otay Ranch was in 3-bedroom apartments, which decreased -10.78%, a decline limited to this specific apartment segment rather than a broad trend across all apartments.
Are rents generally increasing or decreasing in Otay Ranch, California as of September 2026?
Rental segments in Otay Ranch, CA show both increases and decreases for September 2026, such as a 6.22% year-over-year rise for 1-bedroom single-family homes (from $2,588 to $2,750) and a -10.78% decline for 3-bedroom apartments (from $4,051 to $3,614).
What is the rent difference between 4-bedroom apartments and 4-bedroom single-family homes in Otay Ranch?
In September 2026, the median rent for a 4-bedroom apartment in Otay Ranch is $5,509, which is $372 higher than the $5,137 median for a 4-bedroom single-family home.
Otay Ranch, CA· San Diego metro
September 2026
91913
Long-term Rental Rates
Long-term rental rates for Otay Ranch (91913), in the San Diego metro area, as of September 2026.
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,560 – $2,858
1.79%
3.38%
2-Bedroom
$3,130 – $3,494
-4.38%
0.41%
3-Bedroom
$3,398 – $3,831
-11.27%
-10.78%
4-Bedroom
$5,278 – $5,740
0.90%
3.45%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,688 – $2,895
16.13%
4.48%
2-Bedroom
$2,978 – $3,162
0.82%
-0.95%
3-Bedroom
$3,701 – $4,025
3.89%
3.03%
4-Bedroom
$4,917 – $5,274
-6.30%
-2.78%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,640 – $2,860
0.62%
6.22%
2-Bedroom
$3,085 – $3,342
0.70%
-7.19%
3-Bedroom
$3,937 – $4,283
-0.85%
-4.08%
4-Bedroom
$4,829 – $5,446
1.83%
7.93%
Data updated: October 19, 2026
Otay Ranch Rental Trends · San Diego metro
In the Otay Ranch (91913) rental market, 2-bedroom apartments reached a median rent of $3,464, reflecting a 2.13% month-over-month rise. Year-over-year, this segment posted a 5.73% increase, marking the highest annual gain among apartment categories in Otay Ranch (91913).
Across property types, 1-bedroom condo/townhome units in Otay Ranch (91913) dropped 15.76% month-over-month to a median of $2,404. This segment also experienced a year-over-year decline of 9.49%, signaling reduced demand relative to other property options.
When comparing segments, Otay Ranch (91913) rental trends reveal that 3-bedroom single-family homes outperformed 3-bedroom apartments by $71 ($4,145 vs $4,074) and exceeded 3-bedroom condo/townhomes by $427. This segment jumped 5.66% month-over-month, illustrating notable price gains for larger single-family units.
Get the full Otay Ranch rental market report
Current rents by property type and bedroom count, how they have moved over the past year, and what it means for an owner here. Free, by email, from Crestmont Property Management.
Crestmont Realty is a San Diego property management firm serving the San Diego coastal region and surrounding neighborhoods, from Coronado and Point Loma to La Jolla and Del Mar, with select areas across the county. We provide full-service residential management and tenant placement for single-family homes, condos, and small multifamily properties. Crestmont publishes current rental market data for San Diego neighborhoods every month, including rents by bedroom, vacancy, and days on market.
Properties Managed: Single-family homes, condos and townhomes, small multifamily
Target Audience: Rental property owners, investors, accidental landlords, and out-of-state owners of San Diego properties
Market Notes: San Diego rental conditions vary by neighborhood. Crestmont publishes current submarket data monthly, at neighborhood and ZIP grain.